Yes On 1

Most people want one thing above all else when it comes to dealing with the criminal justice system: fairness. But fairness only comes when both sides start out with an equal footing. Unfortunately, that simply isn’t the case for victims of crime in Kentucky who are not provided the same level of constitutional rights as the accused.

Kentucky crime victims need your help, which you can offer by voting YES on Constitutional Amendment #1 (Marsy’s Law) on or before November 3. We need Marsy’s Law in Kentucky because it would finally give victims of crime a constitutionally protected right to be notified, be heard, and be present at key court proceedings without infringing upon the rights of the accused and convicted.

Kentucky is one of only 15 states without constitutional rights from crime victims.

Throughout my time as both a prosecutor and a legislator, I have spoken to many people who have been hurt by the imbalance our current system allows. Their stories of fear, loss, and pain are heartbreaking. But we have an opportunity to correct this imbalance of justice by supporting Amendment #1.

During my tenure as Chairman of the Judiciary Committee, I have proudly championed many meaningful efforts, including criminal justice reform, drug abuse care and prevention, and protections for dating violence victims, not because they are partisan in nature, but because they are issues that matter to all Kentuckians. Honoring the rights of crime victims is no different. Marsy’s Law is a bipartisan, common-sense effort to help victims of crime achieve the justice they deserve. Its list of local supporters spans the Commonwealth, and includes the Children’s Advocacy Centers of KY, KY Association of Sexual Assault Programs, Mother’s Against Drunk Driving, the Kentucky League of Cities, Kentucky Mental Health Coalition, the Kentucky Sheriff’s Association, and the Kentucky Association of Chiefs of Police just to name a few.

In the coming weeks, you’re going to hear a lot about Marsy’s Law / Amendment #1. And as the campaign season kicks into high gear, you will no doubt hear opponents launch ridiculous and unfounded attacks that are not supported in fact or in law.

Amendment #1 does not change the federal and state due process standards for criminal defendants nor does it change existing self-defense and stand-your-ground laws. And nothing changes the presumption of innocence; in fact Amendment 1 reaffirms that protection for the accused.

Some will argue that they support victims, but that giving them constitutional rights goes too far. To those individuals, I would ask – what if it was you or your loved one who was a victim of crime? Are you comfortable knowing that your rights aren’t protected at the same level as the accused and convicted? Wouldn’t you want a constitutional right to be heard and to be present in the courtroom? Wouldn’t you want a constitutional right to restitution? Victims shouldn’t be cast aside or ignored, but should be valued and heard. Victims deserve a voice.

If you agree, then please vote YES on Constitutional Amendment #1.

Kentucky’s constitution protects against government overreach and guarantees participatory rights in government action—protections victims deserve. The constitutional rights Marsy’s Law would provide will improve the criminal justice system by ensuring fairness for all involved.

The need for Marsy’s Law is not hypothetical. Thousands of Kentuckians, including people you know, become victims of crime each year. For them, the need to be protected and given a voice is deeply felt.

When Kentuckians vote this year we will have the opportunity to permanently enshrine these rights into our state constitution. But to ensure this happens, we need your help to spread the word about Marsy’s Law by telling your friends, neighbors and colleagues about the importance of voting YES on Constitutional Amendment #1. (Just keep in mind that you may have to flip over your ballot to find it.)

Let’s make 2020 the year we will finally give victims the protections, the voice and the dignity they deserve. Join me in supporting crime victims by voting YES on Amendment #1.

Have questions about the amendment? Check out the FAQ’s at VictimsRightsKY.com. Most of the tens of thousands of Kentuckians who become crime victims each year have no rights under Kentucky law at all. Together, we can change that on November 3rd. #YesOn1

Moving the Goal Posts

Earlier today, Senate Education Committee Chair Max Wise (R, Campbellsville), along with the entire Senator Majority Leadership team, released an op-ed in response to the Governor’s unexpected and abrupt change of plans, creating confusion and frustration in homes and local school board rooms across the Commonwealth. I fully support my friend and colleague, Senator Wise, in this piece:

Commonwealth of Kentucky

Senate Majority Office

August 11, 2020

Reopening Kentucky Schools? Local Superintendents Should Decide

By Senators Wise, Stivers, Givens, Thayer, Adams, and Wilson

We, members of the Kentucky State Senate Majority, have heard a myriad of disappointment, anger, confusion, and frustration from our constituents regarding Governor Andy Beshear’s ‘recommendation’ that all schools open virtually in the fall of 2020. From parents of high school seniors to grandparents of kindergarten students, we are hearing from them all.

Citizens across the Commonwealth know how vital schools are to their communities, as they play an essential role in preparing their children for the future. Some weeks ago, after sending a letter to the Kentucky Department of Education (KDE) encouraging some guidance to be provided to schools, Governor Beshear’s KDE finally took a position. If districts worked with local health departments, school administrators, teachers, and community leaders to develop well-designed plans that fit their local needs, KDE would review them and offer suggestions. The goal was to get children back into schools ready for in-person learning while permitting districts and families the flexibility if they choose to attend virtually.

Suddenly, yesterday, Governor Beshear unilaterally moved the goalposts. He moved from an initial recommendation to wait until the third week of August to resume in-person classes to now extending that date to the week before schools would be closed for fall break. One of the most frustrating scenarios is that over 100 local school districts were not given a chance to see if their in-person model may work. Surveys were taken, input was provided, and plans were developed only to see a ‘recommendation’ basically corner those superintendents into a box. Are they not to be trusted? Some districts had already announced their initial ‘virtual-only’ plans.

In contrast, many smaller or rural public school districts hoped to follow through on the overwhelming clamor from their teachers, parents, and students to offer a choice and support a reopening for in-person education during the 2020-21 school year. Locally, no voice has been louder than that of working-class parents. Much like when the pandemic began, these parents are being pushed into a financial crisis. Many of these parents have returned to work to now face the additional economic sacrifices and dilemmas of finding childcare, quitting a job, seeking family assistance, or requesting workforce accommodations to comply with this last-minute ‘recommendation.’

At this Monday press briefing, the question was posed to the Governor, “What is the impact of your recommendation on delaying the start of in-person classes until September 28th?” His response, “It is a recommendation. We are basing it on public health advice and the facts right now. If local school officials ignore us, the consequences are theirs.” From the start, the Governor has said, “We are in this together,” but suddenly, now “the consequences are theirs?” This statement and tone indicate blame, finger-pointing, and potential retribution for districts that don’t follow his ‘recommendation.’

“We fully support decisions made on the local level because they have the pulse and the ear of their communities’ safety and students’ best interest. The outcomes of those decisions will likely not be perfect, but we will stand beside those students, families, leaders, and teachers.”

— Senator Max Wise

Regarding public health advice, remember that the CDC director testified that keeping schools closed poses a more significant health threat to children than reopening. Suppose we fail to provide access to in-person learning. In that case, Kentucky’s school-aged children will receive limited or no access to nutrition, immunizations, mental health counseling, speech therapy, and other essential health-related services.

The Republicans of the Kentucky State Senate believe that we should indeed all be in this together. We echo the words of UK President Dr. Eli Capiluto, quoted on July 21, 2020 by the Lexington Herald-Leader. When questioned about the wisdom of his endorsement of students returning to campus coursework and activities, Dr. Capiluto responded, “As I heard someone recently say, we have two choices: we can go into lockdown, shutdown, or we can try to live in a COVID world. I think most of us realize we’ve got to live in a COVID world. So how do we make it as safe as possible for our student-athletes and for those who are dearest in our community — students, staff and faculty? That’s what we’re trying to do.”

In closing, we have full confidence in Kentucky’s education professionals. Their innovation, adaptability, professionalism, and commitment is unmatched. We support districts deciding on their own to start in-person, virtually, or through a hybrid methods. We cannot apply a one size fits all model for our school districts, as what is best for Jefferson County may not be the same for Adair County. We fully support decisions made on the local level because they have the pulse and the ear of their communities’ safety and students’ best interest. The outcomes of those decisions will likely not be perfect, but we will stand beside those students, families, leaders, and teachers.

###

Note: Senator Max Wise represents the 16th District, which encompasses Adair, Clinton, Cumberland, McCreary, Russell, Taylor, and Wayne Counties. He is the chairman of the Senate Education Committee. Senate President Robert Stivers represents the 25th District, which encompasses Clay, Knox, Lee, Owsley, Whitley, Wolfe counties. Senator David Givens represents the 9th District, which encompasses Allen, Barren, Green, Metcalfe, Monroe and Simpson Counties. He serves as the Senate President Pro Tem. Senator Damon Thayer represents the 17th Senate District, which includes southern Kenton County as well as all of Grant and Scott Counties. He is the Senate Majority Floor Leader. Senator Julie Raque Adams represents the 36th State Senate District, which includes a portion of Jefferson County. She is the Senate Majority Caucus Chair. Senator Mike Wilson represents the 32nd District in Warren County. He serves as the Senate Majority Caucus Whip.

The Balancing Test

Rep. Jason Petrie (Elkton) and Sen. Whitney Westerfield (Crofton)

Benjamin Franklin observed long ago, "Those who would give up essential liberty, to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."  Government acts properly when it offers support to the people and does so while holding sacred their constitutional liberties.  Kentuckians grant this limited authority to government to carry out this supportive role, but retain sole authority to decide what is best for themselves.

No one questions that government should take action in times of emergency, but it must be balanced both to meet the emergency and preserve our “essential” liberties.  Rights exist not only in times of peace and tranquility, but also in times of emergency.  Recent rulings by federal courts have determined that Governor Andy Beshear issued orders in response to COVID-19 that failed to maintain the required balance and violated Kentuckians’ constitutional rights.  

Governor Beshear violated the federal and Kentucky constitutions by discriminating against people of religious faith.  Rights associated with religious liberty receive particular constitutional priority.  Arguably, there is no more important right than the right to hold religious beliefs and act upon them. The Governor’s blanket orders prohibited people of faith from gathering at their houses of worship while many other places were left open and encouraged to use CDC guidelines such as social distancing and practicing safe hygiene.  The Governor did not extend the same opportunity to houses of worship.

“Those who would give up essential liberty, to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.“

Similarly, the Governor’s orders unconstitutionally prohibited Kentuckians from traveling.  The right to travel applies broadly among Kentuckians and poses a great threat when restricted.  The mobile nature of society requires the ability of persons to travel without undue restriction, and is especially significant where there is no natural border between states.

Whether constitutional rights are honored eventually is irrelevant.  Constitutional rights are so foundational to our civil society and the balance of power between government and the governed, that they warrant expedited review by courts to avoid irreparable harm.  If the government delays considering an issue, it effectively terminates any real protections afforded by the constitution.  Regrettably, Governor Beshear has chosen in each legal challenge to wait for a court ruling detailing the Governor’s violations before issuing new orders.

Recently, a group of Kentuckians filed another lawsuit against Governor Beshear for violating their constitutional rights to assemble peaceably and protest.  Stationing Kentucky State Police in and around the Capitol to restrict access, banishing demonstrators to a distant parking area, and placing Emergency Response Team members with sharpshooter equipment in and atop the Capitol Annex, evidences a government-first mentality that belies a fear of the very people government is charged with serving.  Constitutional rights cannot yield to the executive branch, especially at the seat of its operations.  Our federal and state constitutions memorialize the fact that the rights of each person existed prior to government, and that those rights are superior to both kings and governors.

Governor Beshear, in particular, cannot plead ignorance of the law or inexperience in government.  The Governor is the son of an attorney, and an attorney himself.  The Beshear family has been in state government for the last five decades. He is the son of a former House member, lieutenant governor, and governor.  Immediately preceding his current position, the Governor acted as Attorney General charged with defending constitutional rights.  This Governor, more than any, should understand constitutional rights and appreciate the necessity of their full protection.

Only during its next regular session, which convenes in January 2021, may the General Assembly act on behalf of the people by modifying existing laws, enacting new legislation, adopting resolutions, performing official inquiries, censuring and impeaching.  Until then, note carefully the actions of this Governor.

###

Rep. Jason Petrie (Elkton) represents the 16th House District, including all of Todd and Logan Counties, and a part of Warren County, Kentucky. Sen. Whitney Westerfield (Crofton), represents the 3rd Senate District, including all of Christian, Todd and Logan Counties. Both legislators serve as Chair of the Judiciary Committee for their respective legislative chambers.

1 Year Budget is Passed

First, I hope this finds you and your family safe and healthy. We’re facing an unprecedented global health crisis, and our normal routines have been upended so dramatically. If you need help, please let me know. You can also reach out to the following local and state resources:

Pennyroyal Center RESPOND hotline (available 24/7/365): 877-473-7766

Kentucky’s COVID-19 Website and hotline: 800-722-5725, or general inquires can be emailed to KYcovid19@ky.gov

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

When in doubt, call your primary care provider.

Many of you have emailed, messaged or called regarding various items in the budget, and on Wednesday, April 1st, the legislature sent a truncated, one-year budget to the Governor for consideration. Regrettably, this budget is based on revenue projections that no one believes we’ll hit in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. All raises for various state employees that have been discussed have been put on hold. Much needed increases in spending on education and infrastructure are almost entirely delayed. However, we are putting an emphasis on public health, unemployment, and along with several other changes to help all Kentuckians navigate these difficult waters, in Senate Bill 150, Kentucky’s own COVID-19 relief bill that was passed unanimously on March 26th and was signed into law on March 30th. The Executive, Judicial and Legislative branch budgets were all passed to cover spending only for the first half of the biennium. The General Assembly will return for its next regular session in 2021 to prepare a revised budget for the second year of the biennium, ostensibly based on updated economic forecasts. I know we all hope to have COVID-19 well behind us by then.

While the General Assembly currently plans to return for a final day (or possibly two days) in mid-April to consider overriding any vetos and to make final passage of other bills, leadership in both chambers are monitoring the emergency daily. The Kentucky Constitution prohibits the legislature from conducting business in an even-numbered year beyond midnight on April 15th. If we don’t return by then the legislature is adjourned automatically by constitutional mandate.

Unfortunately, with the COVID-19 emergency the legislature has, rightly, decided to recess for as much time as possible to minimize potential exposure to staff and legislators. As a result, many bills that were headed toward more debate and possible passage have fallen to the wayside in the interest of the most important policy work, namely those bills related to budgets, pensions, and public health. I feel confident many of these bills will be filed and pursued again in 2021.

Below I’ve included links to key budget and revenue documents, including a summary of the “main” budget document (Executive branch) to show some of the highlights. If you have questions or if I can help don’t hesitate to reach out. You can email me here, or call my Frankfort office at 502-564-8100.

In the meantime, please remember to maintain physical distance in accordance with CDC recommendations and stay home as much as possible!

Senator Whitney Westerfield Announces Re-Election Bid

CROFTON, KY — Republican state Senator Whitney Westerfield will seek re-election to Kentucky’s 3rd Senate district for a third term in office. His campaign will focus on continuing to achieve real results for the district and upholding conservative values.

Westerfield serves Christian, Logan, and Todd counties in Frankfort. He is also a life-long resident of Christian County and has been widely regarded as a workhorse for his district. “I am extremely grateful for the support I have received here at home,” said Westerfield. “Since 2013, I have helped pass bipartisan legislation, fought hard for government transparency, protected the unborn, worked to improve public safety, and promoted economic opportunity for the families in our district. I am as ready as ever to take your voices to Frankfort and lead the charge towards solving our most pressing issues.”

Westerfield has served as chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee throughout his time in office. He sponsored Senate Bill 200 in 2014, which brought about the largest reform to Kentucky’s juvenile justice system in 30 years.

“Slow and steady wins the race,” said Westerfield. “Being a successful legislator requires persistence, which is why I’ve filed for re-election. I have been fortunate to see legislation come to fruition that has been years in the making. I promise to continue expanding opportunities for struggling Kentuckians and reforming policies that inadequately address the real issues our communities face.”

Westerfield’s current term in office stretches through 2020, when state lawmakers will be expected to write a new budget. “We have a Republican majority in Frankfort and a new, Democratic governor at the helm,” said Westerfield. “Looking at that dynamic alone, I can anticipate the challenges that will lie ahead. However, the good people of Western Kentucky expect their state leaders to find common ground.”


Westerfield has been an active member of the Kentucky Bar since October 2006. Because of his practical experience as a local attorney, his legislation has focused largely on improving the justice system and developing services that protect victims of crime. Westerfield’s prosecutorial record has included successful convictions on charges ranging from misdemeanors to homicide.

Kentucky's state Senate elections will take place in 2020. For more details on Senator Westerfield’s record and this campaign, please visit WhitneyWesterfield.com.

###